|
|
Post by Tractorpull on May 7, 2021 14:40:45 GMT -6
Below is this quarters P4P rankings. They are based on statistics generously provided by Girls Friday. Those statistic are modified by me as I consider competition, as I do the the lightweight and welter rankings. To me competition is key when considering won and lost records. Who a fighter has fought and who she has beaten is more import then simple won or loss numbers. These ranking cover activity from May 1, 2019 to May 1, 2021. There will always be a difference between P4P ranking and the usual rankings of BWO and Tractorpull as those ranking cover recent activity, not activity taking place over a two year period
Kate Upton
2. Lily Collins
3. Kendall Jenner
4. Amanda Righetti
5. Naomi Scott
6. Emma Watson
7. Emily DiDonato
8. Taylor Swift
9. Kira Kosarin
10. Bella Thorne
|
|
The Grand Wizard OOC
Guest
|
Post by The Grand Wizard OOC on May 7, 2021 18:49:11 GMT -6
While you can always have arguments about lists like this, which is what makes them fun...I can't see how you can argue with the ten women listed here.
|
|
|
|
Post by Ginny on May 8, 2021 7:46:31 GMT -6
The list could be debated endlessly as to position... but I'm pretty sure just about every manager would agree with (at least) seven or eight of the names. That level of agreement speaks to the validity of the attempt to rank the unrankable. The only way to reach a concensus would be a tournament (which may get a week or two of agreement before cries for "rematch" would start to be heard.) Still, it's always fun to do these kinds of rankings simply because they generate a lot more heat than light...always a good thing for the board!!  |
|
caspian
Local Administrator
Owner and General Manager
Posts: 1,563
|
Post by caspian on May 8, 2021 7:59:59 GMT -6
I'm honestly surprised to see our dear Lily up there at #2. Besides the obvious fact she wouldn't stand a chance in hell in a tournament with the likes of Big Red and Upton, I'm genuinely curious as to why she was ranked so highly above the other girls on the list. What was it that gave her the #2 slot? Part of me also wants to know what we're doing that's considered right in Tess' book |
|
|
|
Post by Tractorpull on May 8, 2021 10:52:18 GMT -6
TESS VALMORE
Well this is a first. I always expect to have defend why a fighter isn’t included or why they are not higher. This is a first time a manager asked why his fighter was ranked so high,
As I pointed out in the rankings the statistics were supplied by Girls Friday which I understand is the same format used in the BBU. To that, I modified the won/loss numbers by taking into consideration the amount of activity and the quality of opponents. Lily did quite well in both. Again the ranking are over a two year period. She wouldn’t be that high if the last six months were only considered
Of course Collins vs Upton or Kendall Jenner would be a joke but if I considered the big hitters the would be no one in the rankings but welters and lightweights. We will usually use two flyweight and bantam under the theory that if the were as big as Righetti or Jenner they would be big hitters. In essence we are tying to tell the rest of the division what they are facing in case they want to challenge
|
|
